Toward Meaningful Transparency for AI Chatbots: Disclosing Persuasive Intent Reduces Persuasion

Key Findings

• — The chatbot shifted attitudes by 12.6 points on a 100-point scale in the control condition
• — Prominent disclosure of AI identity was practically equivalent to no disclosure at all, producing a 13.1-point shift
• — Adding disclosure of the chatbot's persuasive intent and instructions cut the shift to 6.3 points, roughly half the control effect
• — The intent disclosure also led participants to judge the campaign's methods as less acceptable and to support stronger penalties against it
• — The authors conclude that for direct chatbot interactions, transparency about what a system is does not meaningfully affect its influence

Methodology Notes

Preregistered between-subjects experiment, n=1,500 UK adults, 60 policy topics, one short conversation per participant; 30 pages including supplementary information. Primary listing cs.CY, arXiv 2608.11794, submitted 2026-08-12 with the PDF title block dated 2026-08-13. The outcome measured is policy-attitude change, not a relational or mental-health outcome, so whether the same disclosure asymmetry holds in companion or crisis conversations is untested. Not peer reviewed. Verified at the arXiv abs page: citation_title, both authors, citation_date 2026/08/12 and the full abstract were read directly, and every figure above appears verbatim in it.

Sources