Informational Help-Seeking on Reddit Did Not Decline After ChatGPT

Key Findings

• — 26 informational communities against 90 size-matched hobby communities, plus or minus six calendar months around launch, with the same analysis repeated at 66 pre-ChatGPT placebo dates.
• — The design rules out any posting decline larger than 3.4%, against the 8% to 25% declines reported in prior work.
• — An AI-substitution check scored 274,411 posts and 223,775 comments with AI-text detectors, differenced across community types to cancel detector false positives on human text.
• — AI-written posts rose only 2 to 3 percentage points more in informational than hobby communities, short of the 5.1 points needed to conceal even the smallest previously reported decline; comments show no such rise.
• — The authors' own largest estimate, an 18% fall in low-stakes curiosity communities, matches that community type's pre-existing trend.

Methodology Notes

Reddit only; posting volume is a proxy for help-seeking and says nothing about the quality of help received; AI-text detectors are noisy, which the differencing design mitigates rather than eliminates. The placebo-date replication is the load-bearing part of the method. Preprint, not peer-reviewed; arXiv 2609.12447 v1, submitted 2026-09-11 and announced in the 2026-09-14 partition. Abstract page fetched and read.

Sources